You are viewing 50bookchallenge

Previous Entry | Next Entry

15: "How're you?" "In prison. You?"

Partially inspired by this back-and-forth on its significance, I took Watchmen out of the library last week.  You all know the plot: blah blah "and I will whisper 'no'" blah "give me back my face" blah blah 35 minutes ago. 

I've come across so much deconstruction regarding the book going in that the plot wasn't a surprise (though the meticulous detail in the panels was admirable).  What preoccupied my mind instead, then, in a missing-the-point way, was how little I enjoyed the company of the comic's world and characters  -  how I felt like I needed to wash afterward.  And, yes, of course this unpleasantness (to understate prissily) is integral to the book's message.  I find it unfortunate, though, that the grimdark aesthetic was what the U.S. comic book industry apparently took from Watchmen, instead of following in its literary ambitions, its crafting of characters and moral dilemmas that hold up to extended analysis and scrutiny.  (That said, its message is quite self-reflective  -  a treatise on why the concept of superheroes doesn't work  -  and while the argument is well-considered, it still seems a...lesser undertaking than "typical" novel considerations of the human condition and other larger issues.  I'm not claiming Watchmen's message was unworthy, but I wish the Greatest Comic was something a bit less navel-gaving, is what I'm saying.)

A purposefully vague thought concerning the last "I leave it entirely in your hands" bit; does not the claimed context of the closing "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?" quote indeed imply that, well, something was done?

P. S. That site I linked's piece on the Trayvon Martin case, "that's just the way it is.", is the best I've read on the issue and well worth reading.

Comments

( 2 pithy comments — Say something pithy! )
ereini0n
Apr. 1st, 2012 05:26 am (UTC)
This was the only comicbook I've ever read. I liked the film better.
indigozeal
Apr. 1st, 2012 02:07 pm (UTC)
I think this is also the only Western comic I've read, save for a few freebies in high school (and game and what-have-you tie-ins). At trade-length, it's certainly the longest I've read.

I'm going to see the movie this week, but I did catch a YouTube of the big death at the end, and the couple seemingly small changes they made seemed to undermine the scene's power and tip it into the cliche. But I hear Jackie Earle Haley's performance is a revelation, so I'll certainly be seeing the film at length.
( 2 pithy comments — Say something pithy! )

Profile

windowseat
50bookchallenge
50bookchallenge

Tags

Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow