I read these five YA fantasy/horror novels over the last six weeks after spotting the striking feline-themed cover of Book 5 at my local library.
Books 144-145: Witch & Curse (Wicked 01 & 02).
Author: Nancy Holder and Debbie Viguié, 2002.
Genre: Paranormal Romance. Horror. YA.
Other Details: Paperback Omnibus Edition. Witch 361 pages. Curse 291 pages.
Witch opens with 17-year old Holly Cathers, her parents and best friend setting out on a raft ride on the Colorado River. There is a terrible accident and everyone apart from Holly is killed. Her world shattered, Holly discovers that her father had a sister, who is now her legal guardian. Maria-Claire Cathers-Anderson has twin daughters, Amanda and Nicole, the same age as Holly. However, Marie Claire has a secret lover, Michael Deveraux, who is a warlock. He also has sons, Eli and Jer.
Marie-Claire is aware of Michael's magic and of her own witch powers but doesn't know that the Deveraux family has had a blood feud with the Cahor family, the original name of the Cathers, stretching back to medieval times. Michael has been disappointed that neither Marie-Claire nor her daughters have much innate magical powers but when he learns of Holly's existence, he realises that she may be the one that has inherited the family's magical power. So he starts plotting her destruction as evil warlock-types tend to do.
Basically both books are a cat and mouse game with increasingly dramatic events and quite a few flashbacks to the past featuring the activities on the part of the evil Deveraux family and the not-quite-as-evil Cahor family. These flashbacks could have done with greater editorial checking as there were some bloopers. The worse for me was the reference to an upcoming 600-year anniversary from events that took place in the 13th century. Since the modern day events take place circa early 21st century, this literally doesn't add up.
Books 146-147: Legacy & Spellbound (Wicked 03 & 04).
Author: Nancy Holder and Debbie Viguié, 2003.
Genre: Paranormal Romance. Horror. YA.
Other Details: Paperback Omnibus Edition. Legacy 317 pages. Spellbound 342 pages.
The magical feud between the Cahor and the Deveraux families had heated up in the second book and incorporated a larger on-going magical war between witchy factions: one group who follow the Goddess and the other the Horned God. So there is a host of new characters and a great deal of bouncing about as various people get separated, kidnapped, rescued, possessed and the like.
There is also an increasing body count, more pyrotechnics, and nasty entities that overall make
Charmed look tame. In
Spellbound there is a late plot twist that left me thinking WTF! Not sure what Nancy H. and Debbie V. were thinking on that one though again I had to ask myself was there anything really that more outlandish than things that had been done in
Charmed or
Buffy: the Vampire Slayer, both of which were on screen when the books were written.
I also do admit that I have a soft spot for those Gothic horror films of the 60/70s and in here there are plenty of pitch-black, if-it-moves-sacrifice-it baddies that would work well in that kind of film. Holly bothered me as I just am suspicious of a character that goes from schoolgirl to uber-witch in a few months with no training and now is hailed as the 'greatest witch that has ever lived'. Hello Mary-Sue!
Book 148: Resurrection (Wicked 05).
Author: Nancy Holder and Debbie Viguié, 2009
Genre: Paranormal Romance. Horror. YA.
Other Details: Paperback. 416 pages.
Six years after the cliff-hanger ending of
Spellbound, the authors complete the series with
Resurrection. There is more bouncing about the globe (and through time) by various folk searching for other folk, more demons, more revelations, more fireballs, more death and destruction, and some rather dubious returns from the grave. The authors also wove into the story the olde English ballad, Scarborough Fair, which made me want to go burn my Simon & Garfunkle CD. Suffice to say it really didn't work well for me.
The series as a whole was kind of like popcorn: no real substance but once you start eating it almost impossible to stop until the bucket is empty. I think if I had been reading them as a teen before I had any real life experience of magic and witchcraft/Wicca I would probably have been enthralled by them and wanted more. Plus, I did enjoy
Charmed and similar shows and they can be easily as convoluted and daft. I was also pleased that the authors resisted the temptation to introduce vampires into the mix though there was a point I really thought they might. No, they've saved those for their new collaboration.
So overall, they proved entertaining enough and I didn't feel too much outrage at the authors' rather skew-whiffed take on witchcraft and Wicca. .